Thursday, October 17, 2013

"'Sick-lit'? Evidently Young Adult Fiction is Too Complex for the Daily Mail" by Michelle Pauli

Michelle Pauli's response article to the Daily Mail's article "Sick-lit" claims that their opinion of young adult literature being too disturbing and dark is wrong. She says, unlike the Daily Mail's opinion, that the books, such as The Fault in Our Stars, are very moving, and sensitively deal with controversial issues such as terminal illness, depression, sex, and substance abuse.  Michelle Pauli says that young adult fiction writers care about their readers, knowing that what they write will affect them, and so they are sure to make their writing suitable for them. She also says that, unlike what the Daily Mail thinks, young adult fiction often is written to protect the readers, so they can explore the world and its issues in the safety of a story.

Michelle Pauli uses a lot of craft moves to push her idea. She gives her own opinion and tells the reader about her experiences with these books, such as The Fault in Our Stars. She references the Daily Mails's article in a negative light very often, arguing against many of their claims. She also quotes John Green, writer of The Fault in Our Stars, an author named James Dawson, and Kate Wilson, the managing director of publishing company Nosy Crow to back up her claim.


I agree with her opinion on how the books affect the readers. These books give readers insight into real-life problems, no matter how dark they are, but it's safe for them since it's always within the pages. It is, after all, a story, made-up plots and characters, which makes it better than teens learning about and dealing with these issues in the real world, but also helps prepare them should they encounter it there too.

3 comments:

  1. I TOTALLY agree. It helps me sometimes to read YA books when there's problems in my life, and it truly helps. Too much "darkness" is just an excuse to change books into documents. The difference between a book and a document is that books relate to the reader better than a document does. This blog post really makes me want to read The Fault in Our Stars, so that'll probably be the next book I read!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why thank you, Katarina. I actually haven't read The Fault in our Stars, but i kind of want to. I feel like books are great, no matter what, since it IS a story, so no matter how real it seems, if it gets too be too much, then you can stop reading it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i also agree. because lots of "dark" books also have lessons in them. And yeah, nothing in the book actually happened.

    ReplyDelete